Wednesday, September 30, 2009

Custody and Visitation: Upon Divorce, Ex Stepparents Have No Standing to Petition Visitation

Strauss v. Tuschman, 2009 UT App. 215, (Utah Court of Appeals, August 6, 2009).
Stepfather developed a parental relationship with Daughter, a child from Mother’s prior relationship. Upon separation, Stepfather requested visitation with the child. Mother allowed it, and the district court granted Stepfather visitation. Visitation became increasing difficult to facilitate. The district court bifurcated the case and signed a divorce decree. Stepfather continued to attempt visitation. Mother now objected to visitation. The district court continued to enforce Father’s visitation under Gribble v. Gribble, 583 P.25 (Utah 1978).
Prior to the trial Mother filed a motion in limine arguing that Stepfather had no standing under the newly decided case of Jones v. Barlow, 154 P.3d 808 (Utah 2007). This time the district court agreed and found that Stepfather lacked standing. Stepfather appealed. The Utah Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court and found that while parties are married a non-biological father may stand in loco parentis and may have standing to petition visitation. However, upon divorce the biological parent may end the in loco parentis relationship at will. Thus eliminating Stepparent’s standing.
Unrelated note: the Court did not award attorney fees to mother because she failed to set forth a legal basis for such an award.

Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Divorce: Stipulations are NOT binding on the Court—Arbitration of child custody disputes is against public policy.

Bryner v. Bryner, 2009 UT App. 217, (Utah Court of Appeals, August 6, 2009).
The parties reached a stipulation. However, neither the parties nor the mediator put the agreement in writing. Later the parties did not agree to the content of the stipulation. Parties filed cross motions to enforce their respective versions of the agreement. At the hearing, the parties reached a number of agreements, including joint-custody and to arbitrate future custody issues. After the hearing, but prior to final judgment, Father obtained and ex parte civil stalking injunction against Mother. Because of the injunction, the court ruled that it “could not determine the advisability of enforcing the parties’ stipulation.” Additionally, substituting an arbitrator for the district court was against public policy. As a result, the district court awarded mother sole legal custody and joint physical custody to the parties and omitted the arbitration clause.
Father appealed. Father’s brief focused on omitting the arbitration clause, and argued that if part of the stipulation was not adopted the entire stipulation must be rejected. Father never raised this issue at the district court level. First, because Father failed to preserve the issue the Court affirmed the trial court. Second, even if Father had preserved the issue, the appeal failed on the merits. The Court found that the district court has discretion to adopt some or all of the stipulation. Stipulations are not binding on the court and can enforce portions that are fair and reasonable.


Thursday, September 24, 2009

Failure to Marshal=Dismissal; Inheritance=Separate Property; Encouragement≠Enhancement; Repository≠Comingling; Forgery=Unjust Enrichment;

Kimball v. Kimball, 2009 UT App. 233, (Utah Court of Appeals, August 27, 2009).

Prior to the case analysis, the Court summarized the marshaling requirement. In short, when marshaling the evidence the appellant must provide all evidence in support of the trial court’s ruling, and then must identify which evidence carries the “fatal flaw.” Failure marshal results in dismissal. When reviewing the property distribution, the Court that although husband had encouraged wife to wait for a better offer on her inherited stock (which resulted more money for wife), such encouragement was not sufficient enhancement to overcome the separate property presumption on inheritance. Similarly, placing of proceeds from the sale of stock into a marital account does not automatically change separate property into marital property. Particularly if the property is adequately traced out and removed from the joint account. Husband forged several checks drawn against the stock account and could not prove that he was not unjustly enriched (because he cashed the checks without wife’s permission, the trial court inferred that he was enriched). Finally, Husband requested payment of his attorney fees. Wife argued that he had no need because his family had paid for his attorney (in divorce, to be entitled to attorney fees, one must show need, the other’s ability to pay, and reasonableness of the fees). The trial court agreed with Wife, however it made inadequate findings. The Court of Appeals reversed and remanded this issue. Moreover, the appellate court directed that the trial court found need and ability to pay, the court need only find what award would be reasonable, not that the fees incurred are reasonable.

Full Decision available at http://www.utcourts.gov/opinions/appopin/kimball082709.pdf

Monday, August 31, 2009

Paternity: Failure to Comply Strictly with the Statute = Waiver Temporary Residence is a Qualifying Circumstance Appeals: Failure to Preserve the Iss


O’Dea v. Olea, 2009 UT 46, (Utah Supreme Court, July 28, 2009).


Father appeals district court’s order dismissing his paternity claim. Mother and Father had separated before Father learned of the pregnancy. Mother told father she had miscarried. Father learned that Mother had not miscarried, but instead was preparing for adoption. Father registered as a putative father in Wyoming and Montana and contacted LDS family services (the adoption agency). He again contacted Mother; she asked him not to contact her and told him she was in Utah and that he would never see the child.


Father engaged the police in his search for Mother, and made a website to find out about the child. On the website Mother’s mother responded that the child had been born and placed for adoption.


The child was born June 15, Father filed his notice with department of Human Services on September 8, (he testified that he had attempted to send it earlier, but the third party charged with mailing it failed to mail it).


The Court affirmed the trial court finding that because Father knew or should have known that Mother was in Utah, he was required to comply with the Utah statute by registering with Human Services within 80 days. Because he did not, he waived his right to notice.


Full Decision available at http://www.utcourts.gov/opinions/supopin/ODea072809.pdf

Friday, July 10, 2009

Child Support: Social Security Benefits are Not Included in Income for Child Support Calculation


Wolfe v. Wolfe
, 2009 UT App. 186 (Utah Court of Appeals Memorandum Decision July 9, 2009)

Trial court included Father's Social Security Benefits in the Child Support Calculation. The Office of Recovery Services appealed. The Court of Appeals Reversed and Remanded the case with instructions to recalculate the child support without the social security benefits.

Court Noted that U.C.A. § 78B-12-203(3)(b) also excludes Medicaid, Food Stamps, Housing Subsidies, Benefits from the Job training Partnership Act, Supplemental Security Income, Social Security Disability Insurance and General (government assistance).

Full Decision available at http://www.utcourts.gov/opinions/mds/wolfe070909.pdf

Friday, July 3, 2009

Prenuptial Agreement: Interpreted as any Other Contract



Levin v. Carlton, 2009 UT App. 170 (Utah Court of Appeals, June 25, 2009).

Trial Court found that the prenuptial agreement governed the parties' divorce. Wife appealed to the Utah Court of Appeals. She argued that the trial court's interpretation of the agreement was incorrect. The Court found that although it must look closely for abuse at the time of execution of the prenup, its means of interpreting the agreement are no different from any other contract.
Wife also appealed the trial court's narrow interpretation of Husband's earnings. Under the prenup, husband's earnings were to be community property. The prenup defined earnings as excluding income from investments. The trial court adopted the prenup' definition. The Court Affirmed.
Wife also appealed a denial of her discovery request. The trial court had found that the California law did not permit the post-separation discovery request and the prenup's had a choice of law provision choosing California law. The Court found that the prenup can even govern discovery issues during litigation and Affirmed the trial court.
Finally, Wife appealed the trial court's decision of attorney fees. The Court Affirmed the trial court both in denying her request and granting Husband's. This too was based on the prenup provision on attorney fees.

Full Decision available at http://www.utcourts.gov/opinions/appopin/levin062509.pdf

Tuesday, June 16, 2009

Child Support: Child Support Follows the Child


Hansen v. Hansen, 2009 UT App. 152, (Utah Court of Appeals, June 11, 2009).


Trial Court denied Father's Petition to Modify Child Support. Father appealed to the Utah Court of Appeals. Father argued that his daughter was living in a transitional home supported by Volunteers of America. Since support should follow the child, he argued that both parties should pay support to VoA. The Court found that this statute only applied to when a child moves to the other parent, a relative, or the state. In this case, the child is not in the custody of the state for two reasons: (1) Volunteers of America is not run by the state, but by volunteers and (2) Mother is still responsible for the child and has retained custody. The Mother remains liable for the support of the child, including the responsibility to pay school fees, buy clothing, transport the child to the doctor and counseling appointments, attend to her medical needs and pay her medical expenses. The Child also stays frequently in the Mother's home. The Court affirmed; finding that since custody had not changed, child support should not change.


Note: Mother asked for attorney fees. However, Mother failed to set forth a specific legal basis for the award of fees. No attorney fees awarded.

Full Decision available at http://www.utcourts.gov/opinions/mds/hansen061109.pdf

Disclaimer

:: By using this blog site you understand that this information is not provided in the course of an attorney-client relationship and is not intended to constitute legal advice. This blog site should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed attorney in your state.::

COPYRIGHT

:: (c) 2009-2014 D. Grant Dickinson some rights reserved ::